It was with slight nervousness that I decided to start reading Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms. I am almost always nervous doing whatever I do, and diving into this particular novel I was intimidated by the thoughts that my English was too limited I wouldn't understand the long phrases in the book. And then even if I got the words I might not get the meaning.
Ah. I see that I am not making any sense. So. Okay.
Reading the first few pages, I thought of those long days in elementary school when little was understood. I couldn't connect with the scene, the characters that Hemingway laid out. I tried harder to recognize details which made people attribute some kind of holy manliness to him - details that made him the epitome of everything manly. As the novel was set in World War I, and the lead character was personally involved in it, of course there are scenes of bombings, wounded men, men dying in different sorts of circumstances. The lead character witnessed deaths from up close, killed his subordinate for not obeying a command, was wounded himself, and was depicted as having no complaints about the whole ordeals.
What came into my mind was not that this lead character, Frederic Henry, was very manly, a strong man with a steel heart. Instead, I perceived him as distant, aloof. He could manage to get over deaths, it seems, because he could distance himself from whatever happening around him. Or: is that being manly is all about?
Although there are certainly more than just one character in the novel, all of them sound almost identical. Catherine Barkley, Frederic's girlfriend, sounds exactly like him that when the two converse I felt like reading a monologue. But: this is Hemingway, who later went on as the winner of Pulitzer Prize for Fiction! And the Nobel prize for literature! I did find some of his sentences paint a deep emotion I can't really put a finger on. For instance, Catherine mentions that she wants to have her hair cut short, and Frederic doesn't say a thing. Catherine then asks if he doesn't want her to have her hair cut and he chooses not to answer. I recognized this as the strange characteristics that often accompany love: we sometime wish our lover would/would not do something, yet we refrain from expressing the wish because love gets in the way.
That particular scene might make Hemingway seem sexist, however an almost exactly same thing also happens with Frederic. He grows his beard because Catherine asks him to, and at times he thinks of getting rid of it. He keeps the beard however, because Catherine wants him to.
(Did I really just discuss about hair and beard, not insights about love and war and compassion and companionship depicted in the novel???)
All in all, I don't even know what genre this novel is in. Romance? Suspense? Thriller? Or gasp - Literary? It just doesn't fit in any category I can think of.
True, there are some worthy quotes from the novel which show Hemingway's brilliant observations of life. You can easily find them all over the internet. However, what I conclude from A Farewell to Arms are these:
(1) Intimidated as you may, no matter how limited your English is, just dive into that novel people make a big fuss about, and -
(2) You might find out that the Writer Other People Make A Big Fuss About didn't write brilliant dialogues with vivid characters - yet you can't deny the solid proof that he wrote something.
A writer writes. An age old mantra I long to put to use for myself: a writer writes, no fuss, no excuses: A. Writer. Writes.
The only thing I was fit for was to be a writer, and this notion rested solely on my suspicion that I would never be fit for real work, and that writing didn't require any. Russell Baker (1925 - )
Sunday, April 28, 2013
Sunday, April 07, 2013
Writing Longhand
My excuse for not writing in this blog is that I have begun to start writing long-hand in a notebook..but even so, I am still not writing enough.
I am still yearning to craft a fiction, and so far have come up with two unfinished stories which are about nothing with nobody in them.
I did, however, wrote two letters this past month, and I really love how it feels to write letters and now I wonder whether I can earn money by writing letters.
Sunday, February 24, 2013
A Study of Grief
I. A KIDNEY
Marianne sent me an email several days ago, a piece of writing she made for somebody, a beautiful piece as could only be expected of her. It prompted thoughts about grief, and suddenly I found myself awake for the better part of the night, thinking of her grief, my grief.
I thought of the validity of grief, whether one was weak or strong for talking about hers, whether one was always entitled to it, whether my grief was less valid than Marianne's or the other way around.
I want to write her back, letting her know that her grief is valid, perhaps by showing her that I too carry around a form of grief, which I take out from my heart from time to time to observe. And that after observing it, I always want to put it somewhere - preferably in a trash bin - but so far it is not happening yet.
It is a lot of me - this grief - more like a kidney and not a kidney stone; not something you can flush away whether intentionally or unintentionally by drinking a lot of water. A kidney! I will go about my day, blissfully minding my work - then it takes only a sip of water to remind me that a kidney is inside me.
It takes just a word, a letter, an intro to a song, a simple tune - and one is transported back to that grief.
II. A TREE
With love, it is like we plant a tree inside us, only after we have fully realized the reasons why the tree must be there. We have evidence, hard proofs that the tree must be where it is now: the roots entwined our limbs, its heart sucks the blood from our heart, its great leaves are our thoughts, our joy.
It is very reasonable that we ask for equally hard proofs, for valid reasons as to why one day we have to chop this tree down ourselves. One look at its roots and it's clear: weeding them out will be a slow, painful process, and it will cost us our limbs.
Look at the tree, why is it even there, why did we even let it grow this big, if not for the valid reasons we gathered along the way, that tree must grow, so big and strong inside our own psyche?
Does the universe (or god, or the humans who provide us evidence that the tree must grow) not owe us an explanation as to why this tree must now go?
Do we not deserve a closure, at the very least, be it a tiny sign or a thunderstorm? Because it confuses us so much that it pains: the irrational, illogical turns of events that give us no reason to cut off our limbs. We get that our limbs must go, axes are already in our hands, all we ask is, why?
Why chop them off? Why is there not a valid reason? How is one expected to start a process so big, so slow, so painful, without reasons?
III. WALKING AROUND AS A LIVING TREE, WITH A KIDNEY INSIDE
I cannot pretend that a closure comes to me, so a grief can be nicely wrapped and put away. Just like in the occurrence of deaths and other tragedies in life, a closure is rarely provided, and chopping off your limbs does not always mean you are free for life.
I choose to keep my tree, my kidney. Somehow I think Marianne's tree and kidney are too beautiful, she should keep them too. As I am a lot older than her, I thought I knew more - I thought I would be able to tell her how to navigate through life with tree roots interlacing our limbs, a throbbing kidney inside us.
Alas, the truth is, I don't know how. Even in my ripe old age all I can say is that one will walk as one has always walked, one's steps heavier now that the tree is big.
But one just walks - stubbornly if one will -whether or not there is a closure. Whether or not there is a reason. Whether or not one feels up to it.
One just walks. And I know that if the one happens to be Marianne...not only she will walk, she will write, too. Beautifully, as can only be expected of her.
Marianne sent me an email several days ago, a piece of writing she made for somebody, a beautiful piece as could only be expected of her. It prompted thoughts about grief, and suddenly I found myself awake for the better part of the night, thinking of her grief, my grief.
I thought of the validity of grief, whether one was weak or strong for talking about hers, whether one was always entitled to it, whether my grief was less valid than Marianne's or the other way around.
I want to write her back, letting her know that her grief is valid, perhaps by showing her that I too carry around a form of grief, which I take out from my heart from time to time to observe. And that after observing it, I always want to put it somewhere - preferably in a trash bin - but so far it is not happening yet.
It is a lot of me - this grief - more like a kidney and not a kidney stone; not something you can flush away whether intentionally or unintentionally by drinking a lot of water. A kidney! I will go about my day, blissfully minding my work - then it takes only a sip of water to remind me that a kidney is inside me.
It takes just a word, a letter, an intro to a song, a simple tune - and one is transported back to that grief.
II. A TREE
With love, it is like we plant a tree inside us, only after we have fully realized the reasons why the tree must be there. We have evidence, hard proofs that the tree must be where it is now: the roots entwined our limbs, its heart sucks the blood from our heart, its great leaves are our thoughts, our joy.
It is very reasonable that we ask for equally hard proofs, for valid reasons as to why one day we have to chop this tree down ourselves. One look at its roots and it's clear: weeding them out will be a slow, painful process, and it will cost us our limbs.
Look at the tree, why is it even there, why did we even let it grow this big, if not for the valid reasons we gathered along the way, that tree must grow, so big and strong inside our own psyche?
Does the universe (or god, or the humans who provide us evidence that the tree must grow) not owe us an explanation as to why this tree must now go?
Do we not deserve a closure, at the very least, be it a tiny sign or a thunderstorm? Because it confuses us so much that it pains: the irrational, illogical turns of events that give us no reason to cut off our limbs. We get that our limbs must go, axes are already in our hands, all we ask is, why?
Why chop them off? Why is there not a valid reason? How is one expected to start a process so big, so slow, so painful, without reasons?
III. WALKING AROUND AS A LIVING TREE, WITH A KIDNEY INSIDE
I cannot pretend that a closure comes to me, so a grief can be nicely wrapped and put away. Just like in the occurrence of deaths and other tragedies in life, a closure is rarely provided, and chopping off your limbs does not always mean you are free for life.
I choose to keep my tree, my kidney. Somehow I think Marianne's tree and kidney are too beautiful, she should keep them too. As I am a lot older than her, I thought I knew more - I thought I would be able to tell her how to navigate through life with tree roots interlacing our limbs, a throbbing kidney inside us.
Alas, the truth is, I don't know how. Even in my ripe old age all I can say is that one will walk as one has always walked, one's steps heavier now that the tree is big.
But one just walks - stubbornly if one will -whether or not there is a closure. Whether or not there is a reason. Whether or not one feels up to it.
One just walks. And I know that if the one happens to be Marianne...not only she will walk, she will write, too. Beautifully, as can only be expected of her.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)